On St. Patrick’s Day, U2 will unveil their new album Songs of Surrender. Taking a page from Taylor Swift, the forthcoming collection sees the band reimagine 40 songs from their back catalog.
U2’s The Edge previewed the project in a handwritten note sent to fans. “The fact is that most of our work was written and recorded when we were a bunch of very young men. Those songs mean something quite different to us now,” The Edge wrote. “Some have grown with us. Some we have outgrown. But we have not lost sight of what propelled us to write those songs in the first place. The essence of those songs is still in us, but how to reconnect with that essence when we have moved on, and grown so much?”
“Music allows you to time travel and so we started to imagine what it would be like to bring these songs back with us to the present day and give them the benefit or otherwise, of a 21st century re-imagining,” The Edge added. “What started as an experiment quickly became a personal obsession as so many early U2 songs yielded to a new interpretation. Intimacy replaced post-punk urgency. New keys. New chords. New tempos and new lyrics arrived. It turns out that great song is kind of indestructible. Once we surrendered our reverence for the original version each song started to open up to a new authentic voice of this time, of the people we are, and particularly the singer Bono has become.”
Separately, Bono discussed the project in the afterword of his recent memoir, Surrender: 40 Songs, One Story. “During lockdown, we were able to reimagine 40 U2 tracks for the Songs of Surrender collection, which gave me a chance to live inside those songs again as I wrote this memoir. It also meant I could deal with something that’s been nagging me for some time. The lyrics on a few songs that I’ve always felt were never quite written. They are now. (I think.)”
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2023 2:26 pm
Joined:
20 Sep 2006
Posts:
542
I see negative comments wherever this announcement is posted (mainly several FB pages) and I don't think that it's really fair... I mean, I get it, but sometimes reimagined versions are really interesting. Honestly, I prefer it to "super deluxe" cds with several discs of outtakes.
That said, They haven't been inspired or interesting to me since the atomic bomb album (which I really liked).
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2023 3:02 pm
Joined:
13 Aug 2012
Posts:
3120
Location:
Minnesota
To be fair, Renny, I think a lot of the old guys can't seem to put together a consistent album anymore. Their writing days have passed most of them by.
That said, I agree with Joe.... sometimes these re imagined ones can turn out good. The heavy metal band Testament did one years ago and the newer version almost blow out the originals..... meaning, "This is where we are today with these songs."
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2023 1:09 am
Joined:
23 Jan 2015
Posts:
121
To name a few, Foreigner, the Cure, and Squeeze have all released new versions of their old songs. But when U2 does it, they catch flak. Let it go and wait for their new material, which will eventually come.
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2023 12:29 pm
Luckless Pedestrian
Joined:
04 Oct 2006
Posts:
2224
Location:
Brooklyn OWNS this charmer!
Once you start doing "reimagined" retreads...the party's over.
_________________ "One good thing about music: when it hits, you feel no pain." -- Bob Marley
"There's got to be a way to make something louder and pull people in without making it louder and pushing people away. Music's not about pushing people away." -- Jim Scott, in TapeOp #75
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2023 1:06 pm
Puppy Monkey Alan!
Joined:
20 Sep 2006
Posts:
15809
Bannings:
Dwigt Rortugal
Renny wrote:
doesn't any of the 'old guys" write anything new anymore?
what artist, among the 'old guys' was the last to release an album of new songs?
ignoring quality, is van morrison?......neil young?...........john melllencamp?
scroll down the entire first 2 pages of 'new releases" .......there is nothing.
remember now....'old guys (and gals)"
I know the timing of the looking affects things, but I see quite a few on the new release page (not diving into whether they're all bona fide new songs), but I see Uriah Heep, Peter Gabriel, the Zombies, Lindsey Buckingham, to name just a few. And Alan Parsons has had a few the last few years.
Obviously can't speak to the quality of the new material, but I don't think it's realistic to expect 60/70/80 year olds to write the kind of music they wrote in their teens and 20s. And frankly, *we* are part of the problem, the audience at large (not "we" personally). We head to the bathrooms and concession stands when they play new material. We turn the radio station when the new stuff comes on. Not that radio is innocent in that regard.
_________________ Alan
"This is a true story, except for the parts that didn't happen." - Steven Wright
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2023 1:58 pm
The Last Hippie
Joined:
26 Jun 2006
Posts:
28460
Location:
Ohio
alantig wrote:
Renny wrote:
doesn't any of the 'old guys" write anything new anymore?
what artist, among the 'old guys' was the last to release an album of new songs?
ignoring quality, is van morrison?......neil young?...........john melllencamp?
scroll down the entire first 2 pages of 'new releases" .......there is nothing.
remember now....'old guys (and gals)"
I know the timing of the looking affects things, but I see quite a few on the new release page (not diving into whether they're all bona fide new songs), but I see Uriah Heep, Peter Gabriel, the Zombies, Lindsey Buckingham, to name just a few. And Alan Parsons has had a few the last few years.
Obviously can't speak to the quality of the new material, but I don't think it's realistic to expect 60/70/80 year olds to write the kind of music they wrote in their teens and 20s. And frankly, *we* are part of the problem, the audience at large (not "we" personally). We head to the bathrooms and concession stands when they play new material. We turn the radio station when the new stuff comes on. Not that radio is innocent in that regard.
i know, and i get it, believe me.
but i sit here in my chair in fornt of this computer and look at the shelves of CD's to my right and i wonder why so and so hasn't done anything new for so long.
so and so's:
america david baerwald bruce cockburn burton cummings michael mcdonald boz scaggs steely dan,/donald fagen kenny loggins lucinda williams stephen stills eric stewart daryl hall....hall & oates christopher cross michael franks peter cincotti and so many more.
_________________ Incorrectly is the only word that when spelled correctly is still spelled incorrectly.
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2023 5:49 pm
Joined:
22 Aug 2004
Posts:
4636
Location:
Toronto
Look at it this way - it's better / more creative than another repackaged greatest hits collection with a couple of target exclusive outtakes or b-sides. And in order to stay on certain store shelves / recommended lists, they need something.
I'll leave it at that, since the whole "why aren't we getting new music from person x, y, or z" is a whole broader discussion that likely won't go anywhere and is by no means limited to U2.
Post subject: [2023-03-17] U2 "Songs Of Surrender" 40 re-recorded tracks (Interscope)
Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2023 7:15 pm
Joined:
22 Jun 2007
Posts:
2465
Location:
Massachusetts
I was curious about this collection of re-recordings, but, if all or most of the the songs are in the same stripped down, slow, and acoustic style of the first two samples, I'm going to pass.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum