Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sat May 12, 2018 7:54 pm
Joined:
23 Jul 2006
Posts:
17632
Location:
Florida
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Invisible Pedestrian wrote:
Renny wrote:
ELP - my my my
they are right up there with the doors and yes and the who for recycling old material and releasing live archival stuff.
i think their original catalog albums have been on CD on about 3 or 4 different labels now, maybe more.
This is NOT ELP.
It's Carl Palmer's band and he's been doing this for many years now.
I've seen them twice as openers, but it's not my thing.
It is ELP music (and some other material), still as a trio but with guitars replacing keyboards,
So this band has no keyboards and no vocals and yet it's supposed to be ELP's "Legacy?"
I've seen them and in a million years I could not have imagined they could pull this off but not only did they I found it was quite inventive and enjoyable.
The fresh take of arrangement(s) AND the exceptional skill of the musicians made the concert very satisfying.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sat May 12, 2018 8:02 pm
Pure Evil Gold!!
Joined:
26 Jul 2006
Posts:
37648
Location:
Witness Protection Program
Bannings:
Ask Linda
Rick A wrote:
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Invisible Pedestrian wrote:
Renny wrote:
ELP - my my my
they are right up there with the doors and yes and the who for recycling old material and releasing live archival stuff.
i think their original catalog albums have been on CD on about 3 or 4 different labels now, maybe more.
This is NOT ELP.
It's Carl Palmer's band and he's been doing this for many years now.
I've seen them twice as openers, but it's not my thing.
It is ELP music (and some other material), still as a trio but with guitars replacing keyboards,
So this band has no keyboards and no vocals and yet it's supposed to be ELP's "Legacy?"
I've seen them and in a million years I could not have imagined they could pull this off but not only did they I found it was quite inventive and enjoyable.
The fresh take of arrangement(s) AND the exceptional skill of the musicians made the concert very satisfying.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sat May 12, 2018 9:02 pm
Joined:
23 Jul 2006
Posts:
17632
Location:
Florida
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Rick A wrote:
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Invisible Pedestrian wrote:
Renny wrote:
ELP - my my my
they are right up there with the doors and yes and the who for recycling old material and releasing live archival stuff.
i think their original catalog albums have been on CD on about 3 or 4 different labels now, maybe more.
This is NOT ELP.
It's Carl Palmer's band and he's been doing this for many years now.
I've seen them twice as openers, but it's not my thing.
It is ELP music (and some other material), still as a trio but with guitars replacing keyboards,
So this band has no keyboards and no vocals and yet it's supposed to be ELP's "Legacy?"
I've seen them and in a million years I could not have imagined they could pull this off but not only did they I found it was quite inventive and enjoyable.
The fresh take of arrangement(s) AND the exceptional skill of the musicians made the concert very satisfying.
Fair enough.
Personally, I would have never have gone to a concert where a keyboardist and/or signer/bass player tried to replicate Keith and Greg. It can't happen and if it was attempted I would not sit for it.
They are both one of a kind and the best prog have ever offered, period.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 6:18 am
Friend of Jimbo.
Joined:
30 Jul 2006
Posts:
8857
Location:
Sitting on a Cornflake
Bannings:
Banned on the run
I've seen them twice, once whereby Todd Rundgren came out to sing "Lucky Man".
I'm seeing them again on June 29.
So, I can enjoy seeing the legendary Carl Palmer perform ELP music with world-class guitarists (being that the E and the L are dead and gone), or I can sit home and brood.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 8:33 am
Nominated IMWAN's "Wet Blanket" for 2021
Joined:
30 May 2012
Posts:
12256
Location:
Pembroke, Ontario, Canada
DanO wrote:
So, I can enjoy seeing the legendary Carl Palmer perform ELP music with world-class guitarists (being that the E and the L are dead and gone), or I can sit home and brood.
Hmmm....pretty limited options for you. I've never seen Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy, yet seldom sit home and brood.
_________________ “Don’t take life too serious. It ain’t nohow permanent.”
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 10:24 am
Pure Evil Gold!!
Joined:
26 Jul 2006
Posts:
37648
Location:
Witness Protection Program
Bannings:
Ask Linda
Rick A wrote:
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Rick A wrote:
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Invisible Pedestrian wrote:
Renny wrote:
ELP - my my my
they are right up there with the doors and yes and the who for recycling old material and releasing live archival stuff.
i think their original catalog albums have been on CD on about 3 or 4 different labels now, maybe more.
This is NOT ELP.
It's Carl Palmer's band and he's been doing this for many years now.
I've seen them twice as openers, but it's not my thing.
It is ELP music (and some other material), still as a trio but with guitars replacing keyboards,
So this band has no keyboards and no vocals and yet it's supposed to be ELP's "Legacy?"
I've seen them and in a million years I could not have imagined they could pull this off but not only did they I found it was quite inventive and enjoyable.
The fresh take of arrangement(s) AND the exceptional skill of the musicians made the concert very satisfying.
Fair enough.
Personally, I would have never have gone to a concert where a keyboardist and/or signer/bass player tried to replicate Keith and Greg. It can't happen and if it was attempted I would not sit for it.
They are both one of a kind and the best prog have ever offered, period.
I have to admit, when I think of ELP, the first thing I think of is keyboards. That's why it's hard for me to imagine this setup. But if someone saw this and enjoyed it, more power to them.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 1:28 pm
Joined:
24 Sep 2006
Posts:
26163
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Rick A wrote:
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Rick A wrote:
Dr. Chris Evil wrote:
Invisible Pedestrian wrote:
Renny wrote:
ELP - my my my
they are right up there with the doors and yes and the who for recycling old material and releasing live archival stuff.
i think their original catalog albums have been on CD on about 3 or 4 different labels now, maybe more.
This is NOT ELP.
It's Carl Palmer's band and he's been doing this for many years now.
I've seen them twice as openers, but it's not my thing.
It is ELP music (and some other material), still as a trio but with guitars replacing keyboards,
So this band has no keyboards and no vocals and yet it's supposed to be ELP's "Legacy?"
I've seen them and in a million years I could not have imagined they could pull this off but not only did they I found it was quite inventive and enjoyable.
The fresh take of arrangement(s) AND the exceptional skill of the musicians made the concert very satisfying.
Fair enough.
Personally, I would have never have gone to a concert where a keyboardist and/or signer/bass player tried to replicate Keith and Greg. It can't happen and if it was attempted I would not sit for it.
They are both one of a kind and the best prog have ever offered, period.
I have to admit, when I think of ELP, the first thing I think of is keyboards. That's why it's hard for me to imagine this setup. But if someone saw this and enjoyed it, more power to them.
I didn't like it all, and found the guitar playing obnoxious noodling.
I've seen them twice and I'm an ELP fanatic, so I'm allowed an opinion.
I do love that Carl keeps the music alive and I met him after one of the shows in 2013 and he told me there was no point in playing ELP material the same way and this kept it fresh for him and the audience, so more power to him I say.
Just not my thing at all and I tried.
_________________ "We have a great bunch of outside shooters. Unfortunately, all our games are played indoors."—College Basketball player Weldon Drew
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 5:16 pm
Friend of Jimbo.
Joined:
30 Jul 2006
Posts:
8857
Location:
Sitting on a Cornflake
Bannings:
Banned on the run
Jason Michael wrote:
DanO wrote:
So, I can enjoy seeing the legendary Carl Palmer perform ELP music with world-class guitarists (being that the E and the L are dead and gone), or I can sit home and brood.
Hmmm....pretty limited options for you. I've never seen Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy, yet seldom sit home and brood.
The third option is being a clueless shit-stirrer, apparently.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 8:03 pm
Joined:
23 Jul 2006
Posts:
17632
Location:
Florida
DanO wrote:
Jason Michael wrote:
DanO wrote:
So, I can enjoy seeing the legendary Carl Palmer perform ELP music with world-class guitarists (being that the E and the L are dead and gone), or I can sit home and brood.
Hmmm....pretty limited options for you. I've never seen Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy, yet seldom sit home and brood.
The third option is being a clueless shit-stirrer, apparently.
Jason Michael may not realize how much you DO get out DanO. You give JohnG a run for his money in concerts attended.
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 9:05 pm
Friend of Jimbo.
Joined:
30 Jul 2006
Posts:
8857
Location:
Sitting on a Cornflake
Bannings:
Banned on the run
Rick A wrote:
DanO wrote:
Jason Michael wrote:
DanO wrote:
So, I can enjoy seeing the legendary Carl Palmer perform ELP music with world-class guitarists (being that the E and the L are dead and gone), or I can sit home and brood.
Hmmm....pretty limited options for you. I've never seen Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy, yet seldom sit home and brood.
The third option is being a clueless shit-stirrer, apparently.
Jason Michael may not realize how much you DO get out DanO. You give JohnG a run for his money in concerts attended.
...and every now and then John G and I are at concerts together!
Post subject: [2018-06-29] Carl Palmer's ELP Legacy "Live" CD/DVD set with guests Steve Hackett, Mark Stein and David Frangioni (BMG)
Posted: Mon May 14, 2018 7:37 am
The Last Hippie
Joined:
26 Jun 2006
Posts:
28460
Location:
Ohio
Linda wrote:
A "Crosby, Stills And Palmer" tour would change Renny's mind.
i don't know about that one....not a big ELP fan to begin with. i would like to hear stills and crosby cover some of greg lake's acoustic tunes though, could be very nice. crosby singing 'from the beginning".........think about it!
_________________ Incorrectly is the only word that when spelled correctly is still spelled incorrectly.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum