Renny wrote:
Linda wrote:
It's not new, Renny. Some of these Collected sets go back several years. I've just been catching up.
If you would put aside your distaste for compilations and check out some of the tracklists, you might be pleasantly surprised. The third discs on some of these sets do a good job of rounding up stray tracks that aren't usually found on best-ofs.
i don't really hate comps linda, i just hate when essential tracks are left off of them and when they add a new track or two to try to sell the fans the album.
the true fans (usually me when it happens

) already have all the songs on the comp, and basically forcing me to buy a CD for 1 or 2 songs just pisses me off. spotify has been a godsend for these things, when they get them.
for example:
i have every song on these 3 john hiatt CD's except the acoustic stuff (not sure if they have been on an album or not).
the bad company is another good example, 1 new song, and i have all the rest. they did that with the live album and the 2 CD comp.
and there are so many others.
and, IP, i don't buy them if i already have everything on them, you are right, no one is forcing anyone to buy anything.
Now Renny...you are 100% CORRECT about the way these things are often slapped together.
Although we have thousands of examples here's one off the top of my head...
In 1997 Boston issued their only best-of Greatest Hits (always love those imaginative titles).
Off the top of my head I think Boston had 10 hit singles and yet 3 were missing in "We're Ready" (a Top 10 hit), "Can'tcha Say (You Believe in Me)/Still in Love" (a Top 20 hit) and "I Need Your Love" while a weak album track like "Party" appeared as did TWO versions (one, a useless edit of a new song called "Higher Power" which was a damn good song).
The album was remastered around 2010 or so and they had a chance to fix it.
Did they? Nope! "I Need Your Love" was added and so was "I Had a Good Time" and some songs were dropped, but the other hits remained absent despite the fans complaining.
So, whether you like those songs or not, they should be on an album called Greatest Hits!
So, we are in total agreement about how carelessly these collections are usually cranked out!