Post subject: Batman: Second Chances TPB (stories by Max Allan Collins, Jim Starlin, et al) (2015)
Posted: Wed Jul 15, 2015 9:42 pm
Joined:
26 Dec 2006
Posts:
26688
Location:
Center of the Universe.
This was part of the retro-origin period that hurt DC. Sure, Jason Todd's existing origin mirrored Dick Grayson's too much and probably should have been done differently, but it happened. Move on. It's no different than Kid Flash's origin mimicking the Flash's - an unlike coincidence but not worth the confusion of continuity that is going to be the result of changing it. Also, the Starlin story was not that good. Even the previous origin of Jason Todd Robin was better than a kid stealing tires.
With the exception of Year One, this Batman's books were hit and miss for the second half of the 80's. Shortly before Don Newton had left Batman and Gene Colan was stuck with the unsteady hand of Bob Smith as inker on Detective. Moench's writing was more off than on and his Nocturna story seemed to go on forever. Collins was a bore and Starlin turned out to be a disappointment as well. The death of Jason Todd was the beginning of more Robins that diluted the hero's name with each passing of the torch. Barr & Davis had a good run with smilin' Bats, but it was far too short.
Post subject: Batman: Second Chances TPB (stories by Max Allan Collins, Jim Starlin, et al) (2015)
Posted: Wed Jul 15, 2015 11:21 pm
Bigger and Better!
Joined:
01 Jan 2007
Posts:
52207
Location:
WGBS
Night Owl wrote:
This was part of the retro-origin period that hurt DC. Sure, Jason Todd's existing origin mirrored Dick Grayson's too much and probably should have been done differently, but it happened. Move on.
I thought that the original Jason Todd origin was spot on. I thought that the street punk reboot was ridiculous. The stealing the tires off of the Batmobile shtick was way worse than having a second Robin with ties to the circus.
Post subject: Batman: Second Chances TPB (stories by Max Allan Collins, Jim Starlin, et al) (2015)
Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2015 12:11 am
Joined:
26 Dec 2006
Posts:
26688
Location:
Center of the Universe.
DC needs to hurry up and give me the next Tales of the Batman/Don Newton so I can read that Jason Todd origin story again. I loved the Squid and thought that he was a great addition to Batman's villains. Too bad they killed him off, but it was a good death.
Post subject: Batman: Second Chances TPB (stories by Max Allan Collins, Jim Starlin, et al) (2015)
Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2015 12:30 pm
As dull and repetitive as they are
Joined:
17 Apr 2005
Posts:
30345
Location:
PhilWANdelphia
Bannings:
IMWAN Get Out Of Banning Free Lifetime Golden Pass
Night Owl wrote:
DC needs to hurry up and give me the next Tales of the Batman/Don Newton so I can read that Jason Todd origin story again. I loved the Squid and thought that he was a great addition to Batman's villains. Too bad they killed him off, but it was a good death.
Did they fry him up with a little marinara on the side?
Post subject: Batman: Second Chances TPB (stories by Max Allan Collins, Jim Starlin, et al) (2015)
Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2015 6:33 pm
Paroled evil genius
Joined:
10 Oct 2006
Posts:
12548
Location:
Boddy Mansion
Bolgani Gogo wrote:
I thought the Max Allan Collins Batman run was terrible.
It truly was. I remember some comments by Dave Cockrum in an interview bad-mouth the scripts, one of the first times I'd seen someone criticize a collaborator like that.
Even Denny O'Neil made some comments around that time about hiring a writer who turned out to be a mistake. He didn't name the writer, but I couldn't see any way it could be anyone but Collins.
Post subject: Batman: Second Chances TPB (stories by Max Allan Collins, Jim Starlin, et al) (2015)
Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2015 11:10 pm
Joined:
26 Dec 2006
Posts:
26688
Location:
Center of the Universe.
Junkie Luv wrote:
Night Owl wrote:
DC needs to hurry up and give me the next Tales of the Batman/Don Newton so I can read that Jason Todd origin story again. I loved the Squid and thought that he was a great addition to Batman's villains. Too bad they killed him off, but it was a good death.
Did they fry him up with a little marinara on the side?
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum