Oh, I still need to post a review for this release.
Rick A wrote:
Will be interested Linda in your thoughts of the disc upon your hearing it.
Alright, let me put it this way: I've listened to many, many albums by many, many artists at this stage of the game. (I am old!) Personal favourites are firmly established in my heart and mind. So although I continue to collect a lot of new music, it's a genuine challenge for a new addition to crack my all-time top 50. The Onlookers immediately went into my top 5, and I know there'll be some days when they take a turn at #1. That's how good these recordings are. For somebody with my tastes, they're virtually perfect.
The album absolutely crushes the output of all the other British neo-psych bands of the era. I mean, it's not even a contest. But I'll go further than that. Had an Onlookers album been released back when it was supposed to be, while I'm not sure how they would have fared commercially, for me they might have actually supplanted The Jam as THE group of the era. They were possibly better songwriters (without ever lapsing into sloganeering as Paul Weller sometimes did), definitely better musicians ... hey, I think they were better dressers too.




Love that Swinging London clobber. There are different, clearer pics in the CD's insert booklet, which also includes a few informative essays about the band's history. The audio quality is very good, considering. They generally sound better than just demos -- a few tracks feature studio effects and even strings -- and they do seem fairly complete, just not of "perfect" studio quality. I'll guess that a finished Onlookers album wouldn't really have sounded that much different from what's on this disc.
I remember first reading about The Onlookers in a tiny article in Melody Maker (might have been in NME or even Sounds), with a black & white photo of some fabulously dressed musicians, a suitably trippy logo on the drumkit, a description of how they sounded -- The Small Faces, The Beatles, The Hollies, Traffic -- and I was in love. So little info trickled out since then. There was one 45 rpm single, a couple of other tracks on an obscure compilation ... I'd literally waited 30 years to hear all but a handful of these recordings, and they lived up to, and even exceeded, expectations. How often does that happen? The Onlookers can be safely sat next to The Action, Big Star and other legendary giants who deserved so much more success and recognition in their own time than they got.