Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 9:14 pm
My Superman Has a Dog
Joined:
24 Jun 2007
Posts:
60644
Location:
Planet Krypton
Bannings:
1938
I just got Earth 2 #1 based on the positive reactions here.
I'm surprised so many liked it -- it seemed to be the painfully cliched "grim 'n gritty apocolyptic world" that all the previews promised. And hey, Batman shows what a mastermind he is -- "Let's blow up their portal's power source!" No one else on Earth would have though of that -- good one, Bruce.
Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 9:29 pm
Joined:
07 Sep 2004
Posts:
6832
Location:
Valrico, FL
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
I just got Earth 2 #1 based on the positive reactions here.
I'm surprised so many liked it -- it seemed to be the painfully cliched "grim 'n gritty apocolyptic world" that all the previews promised. And hey, Batman shows what a mastermind he is -- "Let's blow up their portal's power source!" No one else on Earth would have though of that -- good one, Bruce.
C-
I felt the same way, plus there was no reason to name it Earth 2. it was nothing like it, it was just another What If world.
Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 9:24 am
My Superman Has a Dog
Joined:
24 Jun 2007
Posts:
60644
Location:
Planet Krypton
Bannings:
1938
Allen Berrebbi wrote:
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
I just got Earth 2 #1 based on the positive reactions here.
I'm surprised so many liked it -- it seemed to be the painfully cliched "grim 'n gritty apocolyptic world" that all the previews promised. And hey, Batman shows what a mastermind he is -- "Let's blow up their portal's power source!" No one else on Earth would have though of that -- good one, Bruce.
C-
I felt the same way, plus there was no reason to name it Earth 2. it was nothing like it, it was just another What If world.
Well, I think Earth 2 is a pretty handy way of titling a series about an alternate reality.
And if the classic version of Earth 2 doesn't yet exist in the New 52, it doesn't make sense to call this "Earth 37" or whatever it would be in the old alternate Earth numbering system.
Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 9:27 am
I Want To Believe
Joined:
03 Dec 2006
Posts:
23617
Location:
Smallville
Bannings:
3
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
Allen Berrebbi wrote:
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
I just got Earth 2 #1 based on the positive reactions here.
I'm surprised so many liked it -- it seemed to be the painfully cliched "grim 'n gritty apocolyptic world" that all the previews promised. And hey, Batman shows what a mastermind he is -- "Let's blow up their portal's power source!" No one else on Earth would have though of that -- good one, Bruce.
C-
I felt the same way, plus there was no reason to name it Earth 2. it was nothing like it, it was just another What If world.
Well, I think Earth 2 is a pretty handy way of titling a series about an alternate reality.
And if the classic version of Earth 2 doesn't yet exist in the New 52, it doesn't make sense to call this "Earth 37" or whatever it would be in the old alternate Earth numbering system.
Whoa whoa whoa, you want to call Classic Earth 2 "Earth 37"?
That sounds like a con.
_________________ Are you ready? Are you ready to jump right off the edge of everything?
Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 11:41 am
Joined:
27 Nov 2004
Posts:
26384
Location:
Now in WAXHAW, NC!!
Bannings:
1
Just finished Batman: Time and the Batman. The art was dark and scratchy. Tony S! Daniels uses to many close ups. Storywise, I have no idea what I just read. They said it was mystery but no one solved anything. Batman and Darkseid? I still don't know what happened. Pretty obviously, this book was the end of a longer story line. Though, I think if I read the whole story, I still would have a tough time.
Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 3:03 pm
Joined:
07 Sep 2004
Posts:
6832
Location:
Valrico, FL
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
Allen Berrebbi wrote:
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
I just got Earth 2 #1 based on the positive reactions here.
I'm surprised so many liked it -- it seemed to be the painfully cliched "grim 'n gritty apocolyptic world" that all the previews promised. And hey, Batman shows what a mastermind he is -- "Let's blow up their portal's power source!" No one else on Earth would have though of that -- good one, Bruce.
C-
I felt the same way, plus there was no reason to name it Earth 2. it was nothing like it, it was just another What If world.
Well, I think Earth 2 is a pretty handy way of titling a series about an alternate reality.
And if the classic version of Earth 2 doesn't yet exist in the New 52, it doesn't make sense to call this "Earth 37" or whatever it would be in the old alternate Earth numbering system.
And normally I'd agree. When Morrison did his earth 2 book, I didn't complain because it was clearly nothing to do with the Earth 2 we know. But with the daughter of Batman, Powergirl etc. that's where i felt they went wrong naming it that.
Post subject: The "I just read a comic book" thread
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 3:31 pm
Joined:
27 Nov 2004
Posts:
26384
Location:
Now in WAXHAW, NC!!
Bannings:
1
I just finished the Avengers: Fear Itself HC. The only artist of the three in the book that can tell a clear story is Romita,jr. Bachalo and Deodato have cool styles but can't tell a story. The way Bendis wrote it was very disjointed and confusing at times.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum