Depends what you mean by best. Most faithful or just the most enjoyable? I liked New Frontier the most.

Just which one you liked best.

New Frontier.

Year One, with Under the Hood close behind. They still do their best work with Batman.

The Spectre short may be my favorite thing ever though!

As it should be.



And then... http://screenrant.com/the-spectre-tv-show-kofi-131801/

I liked that Justice League of Two Earths one. It was really good in my book.

Crisis on Two Earths.

I guess the point is it wasn't an adaptation. I forgot the topic.

I haven't seen any of the choices, then. I saw the first part of New Frontier but kept falling asleep. Not because it was boring, but because I used to Netflix stuff to fall asleep by.

Last time this subject came up,I picked Superman:Doomsday.Haven't changed my mind about it.
Since then,All-Star Superman was released.I enjoyed that just as much as the Doomsday one.
It's a choce between those two---hmm....

[coin toss]

We have a winner.

Of the ones I've seen (Doomsday, Year One, New Frontier, First Flight, Wonder Woman, Public Enemies) it's either New Frontier or Year One. I liked all of them, though (although Public Enemies was at about the level of an average JLU episode). I loved the Jonah Hex and Spectre shorts, too.

I have to go with Crisis on Two Earths. The ways that it differed from the various comicbook sources were very entertaining.....James Woods as Owl Man was pretty cool, and the action scenes were quite thrilling.

there isn't a Crisis option

It's so different from JLA: Earth 2 that I didn't feel it was an adaptation.

My favorite, too.

It's one of my favorites too, just behind All Star.

I couldn't find a thread for the Batman vs Robin movie they did, which blends the Damian Wayne storyline with the Court of Owls one.

There's are full on fight scenes between Damian versus Nightwing and later in the movie, Batman. They look so weird -- whenever Damian is winning, it looks ridiculous. Whenever Batman and Nightwing are winning, it looks like child abuse.

Some of those DC Nation shorts were awesome. I loved the retelling of classic Doom Patrol stories.

Updated the poll to include new options.

I like New Frontier an awful lot, and I hadn't seen it when this thread first appeared. Thanks.

Assault On Ark ham tops my list. Flashpoint is my second favorite.

Still Doomsday,but nearly all of these deserve a vote.

I've never seen any of these things.