Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 10:56 am
Joined:
25 Oct 2005
Posts:
225
Location:
Ohio
Sad. Very sad. I just read that large Kirby book from a couple years ago by Evanier. While reading it I was trying to figure how much the omission of these men was intentional by Stan or honestly taken from his hands by the press. I also wondered to the extent that Stan propagated this belief in his being the sole creator not so much by outright saying he was but by not making a stronger effort to correct this misunderstanding regarding Marvel's creation and who was involved during the sixties and seventies.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 11:09 am
WANKERMASH #1
Joined:
04 Jan 2007
Posts:
59936
Location:
Dear old Blighty
Pope Krysak wrote:
Who wrote it?
My guess would be one of the Editorial staff at what was the equivalent of Marvel UK/Panini back then. But either way, it's an indication & example of a mindset & view that seemed to go uncontested in a lot of these type of write ups back then.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 12:42 pm
It scorched
Joined:
28 May 2006
Posts:
68686
Bannings:
One too few . . .
Tony Vitale wrote:
Sad. Very sad. I just read that large Kirby book from a couple years ago by Evanier. While reading it I was trying to figure how much the omission of these men was intentional by Stan or honestly taken from his hands by the press. I also wondered to the extent that Stan propagated this belief in his being the sole creator not so much by outright saying he was but by not making a stronger effort to correct this misunderstanding regarding Marvel's creation and who was involved during the sixties and seventies.
Stan was out there saying the same thing in the early days. Ditko couldn't put up with it any longer -- it was a violation of his integrity and he left in 1966.
Kirby, as more of the accepted "company man," hung on three years longer, but ultimately had to leave as well.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 12:45 pm
It scorched
Joined:
28 May 2006
Posts:
68686
Bannings:
One too few . . .
I'm enjoying my recent purchase of the Action Heroes Archive. This page is from the issue with the first appearance of the Question, a Ditko creation that seemed to be high on integrity and ferreting out pretenders.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 12:49 pm
Joined:
27 Nov 2004
Posts:
44599
Location:
Now in CHARLOTTE, NC!!
Bannings:
1
Li'l Jay wrote:
Tony Vitale wrote:
Sad. Very sad. I just read that large Kirby book from a couple years ago by Evanier. While reading it I was trying to figure how much the omission of these men was intentional by Stan or honestly taken from his hands by the press. I also wondered to the extent that Stan propagated this belief in his being the sole creator not so much by outright saying he was but by not making a stronger effort to correct this misunderstanding regarding Marvel's creation and who was involved during the sixties and seventies.
Stan was out there saying the same thing in the early days. Ditko couldn't put up with it any longer -- it was a violation of his integrity and he left in 1966.
Kirby, as more of the accepted "company man," hung on three years longer, but ultimately had to leave as well.
Kirby had to stay, as he had to provide for his family.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 1:04 pm
It scorched
Joined:
28 May 2006
Posts:
68686
Bannings:
One too few . . .
Marcus wrote:
Li'l Jay wrote:
Tony Vitale wrote:
Sad. Very sad. I just read that large Kirby book from a couple years ago by Evanier. While reading it I was trying to figure how much the omission of these men was intentional by Stan or honestly taken from his hands by the press. I also wondered to the extent that Stan propagated this belief in his being the sole creator not so much by outright saying he was but by not making a stronger effort to correct this misunderstanding regarding Marvel's creation and who was involved during the sixties and seventies.
Stan was out there saying the same thing in the early days. Ditko couldn't put up with it any longer -- it was a violation of his integrity and he left in 1966.
Kirby, as more of the accepted "company man," hung on three years longer, but ultimately had to leave as well.
Kirby had to stay, as he had to provide for his family.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 1:17 pm
Ancient Alien Theorist
Joined:
24 Jun 2007
Posts:
105334
Location:
The Fourth World
Bannings:
2001
Li'l Jay wrote:
I'm enjoying my recent purchase of the Action Heroes Archive. This page is from the issue with the first appearance of the Question, a Ditko creation that seemed to be high on integrity and ferreting out pretenders.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 1:27 pm
The Modfather; Wizard of WAN
Joined:
05 Oct 2006
Posts:
56205
Location:
Under the Iron Bridge
Bannings:
freely handed out
Hanzo the Razor wrote:
Li'l Jay wrote:
I'm enjoying my recent purchase of the Action Heroes Archive. This page is from the issue with the first appearance of the Question, a Ditko creation that seemed to be high on integrity and ferreting out pretenders.
What's with the shitty lettering?
I'm surprised there's color. Ditko's non-big-two work is basically fanzines and might as well be stapled together xeroxes as far as production quality. His art is fine, but that's it
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 1:31 pm
It scorched
Joined:
28 May 2006
Posts:
68686
Bannings:
One too few . . .
So I guess what I'm saying, Jeff, is that your comment would really apply to his work outside of Big Two plus Charlton.
And for the Warren work (Creepy, etc.), it was black and white but the production value was great -- the work of 1960's Warren was awesome, the heir apparent to EC Comics, in my view.
Post subject: If YOU were Kirby or Ditko how would YOU feel about THIS?...
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 3:39 pm
Joined:
27 Nov 2004
Posts:
44599
Location:
Now in CHARLOTTE, NC!!
Bannings:
1
Li'l Jay wrote:
Marcus wrote:
Li'l Jay wrote:
Tony Vitale wrote:
Sad. Very sad. I just read that large Kirby book from a couple years ago by Evanier. While reading it I was trying to figure how much the omission of these men was intentional by Stan or honestly taken from his hands by the press. I also wondered to the extent that Stan propagated this belief in his being the sole creator not so much by outright saying he was but by not making a stronger effort to correct this misunderstanding regarding Marvel's creation and who was involved during the sixties and seventies.
Stan was out there saying the same thing in the early days. Ditko couldn't put up with it any longer -- it was a violation of his integrity and he left in 1966.
Kirby, as more of the accepted "company man," hung on three years longer, but ultimately had to leave as well.
Kirby had to stay, as he had to provide for his family.
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 1 guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum