Dental Floss Tycoon wrote:
Geff, how are those Ellington Treasury shows on Storyville? As much Ellington as I have, I never got around to picking up any of those.
How much do you like the DE RCA period right after Blanton-Webster; & right before the 1946-47 Musicraft recordings?
If you like that period, you'll probably like these. (Do you remember the OLD 1944-46 RCA Black, Brown & Beige 3 cd set? That's the same time frame these are from; well so far 44-45)
As I'm a DE completest I have all of them. I don't consider them essential, but they are enjoyable, & as a bonus each volume has liner notes written by a different DE scholar; they also have a few htf tracks
2 negatives:
1. To me, after awhile they all start sounding the same. While there are definitely some things to like about this period (especially Ray Nance & Kay Davis who along with Ivie Anderson were likely DE's best vocalists ever), to me this wasn't one of his most creative periods.
2. A couple of the later volumes (I can't remember which ones) were poorly produced with tons of added reverb. Even folks on the DE list who usually aren't nearly as picky as I about sound were unhappy. I could be wrong here (I'm really tired), but I THINK due to declining health Jack Towers & Jerry Valburn had less to do with the later volumes on cd, & sadly they both passed last year
One general good idea with Storyville: if it was released while Karl Knudsen (the original owner) was alive the quality control is likely quite high. While they still release some great stuff, it's a bit more hit & miss today.
With all of that said, I do own all of them. There also have been a number of significant Storyville sales the last couple years including this series. One source is to subscribe to Allegro's newsletter; when they do their blow out sales, they have the best prices.
Storyville has really slowed down on the speed of release. They're up to V14 of 24 that were originally planned. I don't know if I'd count on all of the final 10 making it out. Knudson, Jerry Valburn & Jack Towers are gone, & the series was really Jerry's baby as they were taken straight of collector's LP's that JV originally released & if my aging memory serves, Jack Towers did the transfers on the first few.
To the best of my knowledge, Carl Haalstrom is the only one of the Storyville old timers left, & I'm pretty sure he is no longer associated with the company.
Hope that helped (probably more than you wanted to know!). I'd say they're more for hard core collector's than a casual fan; but any fan would likely be able to enjoy pretty much any 1 or 2 of the volumes. The best bet may be to find the cheapest price on Amazon or ebay on any of the first 8 or so, & buy 1 & see what you think. Do stay away from the "manufactured on demand" cdr's; all are still around on real factory pressed cd with full liner notes, although Amazon seems to have stopped carrying the factory pressed.