I can't find my copy at the moment..minor filing snafu...so I can't dispute what Jimbo said. I know that it wasn't all that available even when it was released.

Jim is correct. I have one.

Christmas In Fallujah is available on EBAY, Someone in Australia wants around 30 dollars + shipping for a copy....

Wow, never saw or even heard about this one.

Rick A.

It was pretty bad.

Someone in this folder mentioned that "You're Only Human" and "The Night Is Still Young" were written much before their 1985 release on Billy's "Greatest Hits" CD. I found this to be quite surprising so I looked up the song on Wikipedia, where it says it was WRITTEN in 1985:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You%27re_Only_Human

(and so was the follow-up "The Night Is Still Young"). Not that everything in Wikipedia is the gospel truth, but I've read nowhere else (except that one person's comment in this folder) about the song being from an earlier time. If anyone knows anything different, can you please post here?

Just got this new on Discorama for 10.99. I wasn't100% sure I was going to get it, but at the price I was forced into it!
I am looking forward to it-haven't heard the album itself since High School.

I actually never owned it before on either lp or CD. Of course alot of that was due to the 2 big overplayed hits here in NY.
You really didn't need to ever own a Billy Joel album in NY because he was on the radio all the time.

I'm not gonna lie-listening to the song "Piano Man" will be difficult. It's a great song, especially the lyric, but it nauseates me to no end now. The rest of the album however will sound fresh to me even though "Captain Jack" and "Ballad Of Billy The Kid" used to be overplayed in Philly.
Of course, it was Philly that broke Billy's career with the concert on Disc 2 on WMMR and "Captain Jack" in particular. He'd never get away with not playing that here.

IP, you're having much better luck than I with Discorama at the moment. Both the Tull & Joel were gone when I got there. I used to check the site daily, guess I should start again. They did a few things that pissed me off.

"The Ballad of Billy The Kid" is played on a NY classic rock station every day. Every day like clockwork. We don't hear "Piano Man" or "Captain Jack" as much anymore.

has there been any mention when the rest of the albums will be released in this deluxe format, I really hope songs in the attic is included with a disc of extra live tracks,

There was a promo only 1 sided live album (side 2 was a studio best of) from the Stranger Tour that I would still like to see an official release of. It was not included in the Stranger Deluxe.

Hey Geff...was that a white album with Billy Joel in a cartoon form?

It was white, I don't remember the cartoon either way. I once owned it. I saved a dat copy when I sold mine a few years ago.

It was this:

Damn Linda, you are good...

Yep, that's the one.

I had that one also.

There's a truly fantastic article any Billy Joel fan would want to read from Tuesday's Philadelphia Daily News by music critic Jonathan Takiff who also did the liner notes for the new remaster. It goes into great detail about how he got involved in the Sigma Sound concert and how Philly jump-started Joel's career (I didn't know he's played 56 sellouts in Philly-holy shit!).
Anyway, I pieced together all 4 pages and took out of all the ads (sorry philly.com). But this is truly great stuff and proof that without Philly, Billy might never have made it.


Jonathan Takiff: Billy, the Philly kid

November 08, 2011|By Jonathan Takiff

BILLY AND Philly.

We've always been a team.

Billy Joel has played and sold out more shows (56) at our South Philadelphia arenas and stadiums than any other solo artist.

And while this brashly gregarious, immensely gifted singer/keyboardist/composer has moved more than 150 million albums worldwide, local fans have been in his corner and buying his music the absolute longest.


For proof, look no further than the gatefold Billy Joel CD package hitting stores today and also available in download form, with liner notes by yours truly - but more on that later.

First glance suggests it's just a newly remastered, legacy edition of his Columbia Records debut album "Piano Man," first launched in November 1973. But a close inspection of the label reveals that this two-disc set also features a "previously unreleased restored WMMR radio broadcast" from 18 months before: April 15, 1972.

Yup, it's that famous and oft-bootlegged show from Sigma Sound Studios on 12th Street, carried live on 93.3 FM. It was one of those rare, "go out there a nobody, come back a star" nights, and it transformed the Piano Man's career.

Decades later, guess what? This extra-lively hour of music (newly remixed and slightly tweaked by Frank Filipetti) still kicks major butt. Much more so, frankly, than any of Joel's early studio albums - an observation with which the artist heartily concurs.

Then a virtual unknown with a whole lot to prove, Joel pumped up his radio power hour with enough adrenaline to fuel a football team, with confidence and humor that made him your instant best friend and with an amazing set of mostly new material. And how about his take-no-prisoners touring band, including a super-splashy, New Zealand-born percussionist named Rhys Clark, whom Joel encouraged to "beat the crap" out of his drums. The guy could have given The Who's Keith Moon a run for the money.

By contrast, Joel's early studio albums - until his 1976, self-produced "Turnstiles" - were cut and polished with professional studio musicians "who didn't have the sense of commitment and camaraderie . . . the fire in their belly," Joel shared with me not long ago.

Adding insult to injury, Joel says he "hates" the sweet upper register of his early recordings, then de rigueur for sensitive young singer-songwriters. During his WMMR hour, though, Joel got to pitch some growling, ballsy tones more akin to the "rough and gruff" style he'd grow into.


Page 2 of 4)


So am I unduly prejudiced toward the man and this historic radio show? Absolutely! Never has this music chronicler been such an integral part of the story, pushed my passion harder or felt such positive feedback.

Note the picture of me that accompanies this piece. I was awarded that gold record for my part in making "Piano Man" a hit. Took almost two years for the album to reach the prerequisite half-million sales mark, though now it's four times "platinum," denoting 4 million copies sold just in the U.S. (Later Joel albums like "The Stranger," "52nd Street," "Glass Houses" and "An Innocent Man" proved far more successful and sold a whole lot faster.)

Joel and his archivist, Jeff Schock, invited me to write the liner notes for the "Piano Man"/WMMR Concert package, encouraging me to tell the story from my participatory perspective.

I sought input from other participants, such as radio concert producer Dennis Wilen, then-Columbia Records chief Clive Davis and, of course, Mr. J himself.

Until now, no other music writer or Joel biographer has bothered to get this story right. Even Joel's performing daughter Alexa Ray Joel didn't know the fine details of how her dad's career was kick-started in Philadelphia until I shared the saga with her during an interview. I suspect Alexa Ray went back to dad for confirmation, which also may have nudged him to hire me for the liners. Thank you, hon!

Here's the long and short of my part in the Billy Joel story. Back in the early '70s I had two jobs - writing about music and theater for the Daily News and doing weekend late-night air shifts on WMMR, a young, loose, "art for art's sake" kind of progressive rock operation. Highly esteemed and reasonably popular, it was nothing like the hard-rock mega-machine 'MMR is today.

I'd first fallen for Joel's music on his 1971 solo debut album, "Cold Spring Harbor."

At the time, James Taylor, Elton John and Jackson Browne were also just getting off the ground. Some critics had already dismissed Joel as a "Harry Chapin wannabe." But I heard far more variety and depth in this New Yorker's music - even classical and Broadway influences that appealed to my eclectic Philly upbringing.


Page 3 of 4)


So I jumped at the chance to interview Joel and check out his first show at the Main Point in Bryn Mawr. When WMMR radio concert producer Wilen asked about doing a show with Joel, I urged him to go for it. The man was AWESOME in concert. And I'd heard new songs at the Point that blew away almost everything on his debut album. One, in particular, that almost made me fall off my seat.

That special song was "Captain Jack," a pungent, pitiless appraisal of wasted suburban youth. As it had at the Point, the tune killed during the Sigma radio concert. "Captain Jack" dares to murmur the word "masturbate," a sexy shocker I'd never heard uttered in a song before. And then there's that rousing chorus, "Captain Jack will get you high tonight."

Just after the Sigma Sound performance, you'll hear Joel ruminating how the song probably would never make it as a radio single " 'cause we'd have trouble getting it played."
But this wacky free spirit wasn't letting fear of Federal Communications Commission recriminations get in my way. Duty called, no, demanded that I play this powerful and honest piece of work for my freaky, fun-lovin' late-night radio listeners. Jeez, Joel had even customized the concert performance with his wry bummer of a line, "Ah, but there ain't no place to go anyway except Phil-a-del-phi-a, and what for?"

The next time I went into WMMR, after business hours, I found the two-track tape of the Sigma show and secretly ran off a cartridge copy of "Captain Jack." I started cranking it up on my Friday and Saturday shows, getting goose bumps every time. Didn't run it past the music director. Didn't even consider if the station had the legal right to play it.

I had the song exclusively for all of three weeks before other WMMR DJs started getting calls for it on the request line. After our resident British jock, Luke O'Reilly, confronted me, I came clean to its origins. Another copy was run off and permanently installed in the studio, where the likes of Johnny Craft, Ed Sciaky, Michael Tearson, Lyn Kratz and fellow part-timers David Dye and Carol Miller would jump on it, too.


Page 4 of 4)


As recalled in the album notes, WMMR's "old school" general manager at the time, Joel Samuelson (always sleeping soundly when I was on the air), went nuts when he finally got wind of "Captain Jack" and immediately called for its banning. But our freewheeling program director, Jerry Stevens, somehow convinced Samuelson that it was "already too big to ignore."

The song went on to become the most-requested tune in the radio station's prog-era history, demanded more often than "Stairway to Heaven," "Hey Jude" or even "Freebird."
Via bootleg recordings of the 'MMR gig, the saga of "Captain Jack" also burned the airwaves on other, mostly East Coast radio stations. "I'd launch into the song at a college concert in Bum----sville, and people would start to applaud," Joel recalled.

And yes, all that fuss and excitement clearly enticed Columbia to sign Joel to a recording contract that led to "Piano Man," which featured "Captain Jack" as its grand finale. Columbia's then-Philadelphia branch manager, Herbie Gordon, told me that the song "got the folks in New York very excited about Billy."

"But it was just one factor in our decision to sign him," Clive Davis stressed recently.

You remember it your way, dude. I'll tell it mine.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Also out today to mark the artist's 40th anniversary of recording is a 15-CD set, "Billy Joel, The Complete Albums Collection." While boasting one disc of rarities and special publications, this remastered package does not include the Sigma Sound/WMMR concert.

i will be buying this, I'm just waiting to nab one of the many on ebay cheap!

I paid $16 at my indie store.