Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Thu Jul 20, 2017 12:00 am
I love Music & hate brickwalled audio
Joined:
27 Sep 2006
Posts:
37646
Location:
The Pasture
I Loved Curry so much in Rocky Horror that as a teen I bought his solo albums with high hopes............ that were dashed. I was never able to get into anything musical from him other than Rocky.
_________________ Putty Cats are God's gift to the universe.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Thu Jul 20, 2017 12:05 am
Joined:
03 Aug 2006
Posts:
5070
Location:
Pasadena, CA
Geff R. wrote:
I Loved Curry so much in Rocky Horror that as a teen I bought his solo albums with high hopes............ that were dashed. I was never able to get into anything musical from him other than Rocky.
Although I'm not crazy about his albums, there were a few tracks I liked. And I loved I Do the Rock.
_________________ ~Dean~
If I had a million thumbs I'd twiddle, twiddle. But I just have two.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Fri Aug 04, 2017 11:13 pm
Joined:
23 Mar 2008
Posts:
102
Location:
Byron Center, Michigan, USA
Blair G. wrote:
Not familiar with this label How have their previous releases sounded?
Apparently, the label lives up to its name. I read that the Tim Curry "Fearless" reissue from earlier this year had horrible, brick-walled sound. Perhaps someone else can confirm.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Fri Aug 04, 2017 11:36 pm
Helpful Librarian
Joined:
Day WAN
Posts:
196981
Location:
IMWAN Towers
Bannings:
If you're not nice
Bellenger1981 wrote:
Blair G. wrote:
Not familiar with this label How have their previous releases sounded?
Apparently, the label lives up to its name. I read that the Tim Curry "Fearless" reissue from earlier this year had horrible, brick-walled sound. Perhaps someone else can confirm.
The Amazon UK listing for Fearless has six reviews -- five are perfect (with one citing "brilliant" remastering), and the other is what you're remembering:
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 1:57 pm
Joined:
23 Mar 2008
Posts:
102
Location:
Byron Center, Michigan, USA
Linda wrote:
Bellenger1981 wrote:
Blair G. wrote:
Not familiar with this label How have their previous releases sounded?
Apparently, the label lives up to its name. I read that the Tim Curry "Fearless" reissue from earlier this year had horrible, brick-walled sound. Perhaps someone else can confirm.
The Amazon UK listing for Fearless has six reviews -- five are perfect (with one citing "brilliant" remastering), and the other is what you're remembering:
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 2:10 pm
Joined:
23 Mar 2008
Posts:
102
Location:
Byron Center, Michigan, USA
The point is ... what if the bad review is correct? What if these files are MP3 sourced? What if the music is brick-walled? Brick-walled sound may be fine to some people's ears, and others may not notice the sound quality issue because they are listening on headphones. I've read numerous reviews praising sound quality of other releases only to be disappointed myself in harsh, brittle sound. Regardless, sound quality is a matter of opinion. I'll pass on this release for now.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 2:26 pm
I love Music & hate brickwalled audio
Joined:
27 Sep 2006
Posts:
37646
Location:
The Pasture
Bellenger1981 wrote:
The point is ... what if the bad review is correct? What if these files are MP3 sourced? What if the music is brick-walled? Brick-walled sound may be fine to some people's ears, and others may not notice the sound quality issue because they are listening on headphones. I've read numerous reviews praising sound quality of other releases only to be disappointed myself in harsh, brittle sound. Regardless, sound quality is a matter of opinion.
Many consumers have drank the record companies kool-aid.
_________________ Putty Cats are God's gift to the universe.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 2:32 pm
Helpful Librarian
Joined:
Day WAN
Posts:
196981
Location:
IMWAN Towers
Bannings:
If you're not nice
Taken all together, Amazon's reviews are a better gauge, in my experience.
Whenever I run into a self-described "audiophile review", it always seems to have been written from the same script. Everything is brickwalled, the previous remasters were better, the '80s flat transfer is best of all, a needledrop from the original vinyl is superior (or inferior, depending on the intention of the reviewer), only one or two engineers are qualified to remaster everything on Earth, and so on. That's hard to take seriously after a while. It might be correct in this case.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 2:39 pm
Joined:
23 Mar 2008
Posts:
102
Location:
Byron Center, Michigan, USA
Geff R. wrote:
Bellenger1981 wrote:
The point is ... what if the bad review is correct? What if these files are MP3 sourced? What if the music is brick-walled? Brick-walled sound may be fine to some people's ears, and others may not notice the sound quality issue because they are listening on headphones. I've read numerous reviews praising sound quality of other releases only to be disappointed myself in harsh, brittle sound. Regardless, sound quality is a matter of opinion.
Many consumers have drank the record companies kool-aid.
Including myself. Years ago I used to love the loudness of these "remasters". I am not against loudness and dynamic compression. I'm just against too much of it, in which the resulting sound is harsh and brittle. That's not say that I haven't enjoyed some loud remasters in recent years, as long as they don't hurt my ears.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 2:42 pm
Joined:
23 Mar 2008
Posts:
102
Location:
Byron Center, Michigan, USA
Linda wrote:
Taken all together, Amazon's reviews are a better gauge, in my experience.
Whenever I run into a self-described "audiophile review", it always seems to have been written from the same script. Everything is brickwalled, the previous remasters were better, the '80s flat transfer is best of all, a needledrop from the original vinyl is superior (or inferior, depending on the intention of the reviewer), only one or two engineers are qualified to remaster everything on Earth, and so on. That's hard to take seriously after a while. It might be correct in this case.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 2:58 pm
I love Music & hate brickwalled audio
Joined:
27 Sep 2006
Posts:
37646
Location:
The Pasture
I see 2 major issues with the "Hoffman World"
1. Steve is GOD. No one is allowed to say anything that doesn't deify him. Heavy handed moderating in general.
2. I've seen this in the entire hi-end community since I became interested in 1992:
A huge tendency to be really nasty, mean & flame each other. (Look at the old 90's letters to the editor section in Stereophile. this isn't just an internet phenomena). I have no idea why; I rarely to never practiced that behavior. And a 90+% exclusion of 1/2 of the human race, Women.
_________________ Putty Cats are God's gift to the universe.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sun Aug 06, 2017 3:00 am
Joined:
23 Mar 2008
Posts:
102
Location:
Byron Center, Michigan, USA
Geff R. wrote:
I see 2 major issues with the "Hoffman World"
1. Steve is GOD. No one is allowed to say anything that doesn't deify him. Heavy handed moderating in general.
2. I've seen this in the entire hi-end community since I became interested in 1992:
A huge tendency to be really nasty, mean & flame each other. (Look at the old 90's letters to the editor section in Stereophile. this isn't just an internet phenomena). I have no idea why; I rarely to never practiced that behavior. And a 90+% exclusion of 1/2 of the human race, Women.
I agree, too! I actually don't visit the Hoffman forum very often. In fact, I haven't really ever done much research on Steve Hoffman himself. Isn't he just a mastering engineer? I only check the forum in order to gather information and/or opinions on certain releases. There are people on there who do provide good information, regardless, especially when it comes to MP3/lossy sourced material or vinyl sourced material. I do not agree with certain people when it comes to audio mastering. For example, I like the 2011 Bob Ludwig remasters of Queen's back catalog. Even though I think that the music is a bit too loud and brick-walled, I think that it still sounds good and stays true to the original music.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sun Aug 06, 2017 3:19 am
I love Music & hate brickwalled audio
Joined:
27 Sep 2006
Posts:
37646
Location:
The Pasture
Afaik, Hoffman is mostly a mastering engineer. Oddly, he did some very good-excellent work on cd for his DCC label in the old days; to my ears his work isn't nearly as good on SACD (hi-res) or the AF cd's; though their are some positive exceptions. His recent Spirit SACD's were a terrible disappointment to me.
As much as I complain about brightness, these days Hoffman has a tendency on alot (not all) of his AF work to sound too dull & lifeless imo.
_________________ Putty Cats are God's gift to the universe.
Post subject: [2017-09-08] Tim Curry "Read My Lips" expanded remaster (Bad Reputation France)
Posted: Sun Aug 06, 2017 8:15 am
Joined:
03 Aug 2006
Posts:
748
Location:
Delta BC
Bannings:
None....yet
Geff R. wrote:
Afaik, Hoffman is mostly a mastering engineer. Oddly, he did some very good-excellent work on cd for his DCC label in the old days; to my ears his work isn't nearly as good on SACD (hi-res) or the AF cd's; though their are some positive exceptions. His recent Spirit SACD's were a terrible disappointment to me.
As much as I complain about brightness, these days Hoffman has a tendency on alot (not all) of his AF work to sound too dull & lifeless imo.
I spend a lot of time over at the SH Forum and find it OK most of the time though it does get heavy handed once in awhile. And certain posters continue to force their stubborn opinions with great regularity, but I just shake my head and move on to the next thread. I agree that his work with DCC sounds better (or is it just different?) than the AFs. I have two friends, both very into sound quality and active at SHF, that concur.
Users browsing this forum: Apple [Bot], Ocean Doot and 7 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum